 Loni CoombsSelf - Former Criminal Prosecutor | Self - Former Criminal Prosecutor |
| PPhyliss FirecrowSelf - Former Tribal Police Officer | Self - Former Tribal Police Officer |
| PPaula StopsSelf - Henny's Mother | Self - Henny's Mother |
| NNate StopsSelf - Henny's Step-Father | Self - Henny's Step-Father |
| RRynalea Whiteman PeñaSelf - Northern Cheyenne President | Self - Northern Cheyenne President |
| CChris JorgensenSelf - Editor, Billings Gazette | Self - Editor, Billings Gazette |
| AAlvin Not Afraid Jr.Self - Crow Tribe Chairman | Self - Crow Tribe Chairman |
| BBrandon WooleySelf - Billings Police Department | Self - Billings Police Department |
| MMike TothSelf - Private Investigator | Self - Private Investigator |
 Joseph Scott MorganSelf - Forensics Expert | Self - Forensics Expert |
 Joanelle RomeroSelf - Sex Trafficking Survivor | Self - Sex Trafficking Survivor |
 Cyril WechtSelf - Forensic Pathologist | Self - Forensic Pathologist |
| AAnannda Jae'i LittlebirdSelf - Kaysera's Sister | Self - Kaysera's Sister |
| YYolanda FraserSelf - Kaysera's Grandmother | Self - Kaysera's Grandmother |
| AAngelena BellSelf - Selena's Grandmother | Self - Selena's Grandmother |
| TTayzha StewartSelf - Selena's Friend | Self - Selena's Friend |
