| RRobyn GriggsLisa | Lisa |
| JJayson GarityKevin Wright / Student | Kevin Wright / Student |
| HHeather SummersLucy | Lucy |
| MMichael HantonKenny White | Kenny White |
| KKen SechristDetective Pete Williams / Angry Old Motorist / Radio Evangelist | Detective Pete Williams / Angry Old Motorist / Radio Evangelist |
| MMatthew TurnerTom Stone / Student | Tom Stone / Student |
| LLindsay GerishMichelle Clark | Michelle Clark |
| MMildred BoronMrs. Simpson | Mrs. Simpson |
| HHolly SechristMichelle's Friend / Crime Scene Worker | Michelle's Friend / Crime Scene Worker |
| SSteve YeanyBagboy | Bagboy |
| JJoseph J. ZettsSatanic Sam And The Pentagrams: Lead Vocal/Guitar / Lawyer | Satanic Sam And The Pentagrams: Lead Vocal/Guitar / Lawyer |
| BBradley T. SheridanSatanic Sam And The Pentagrams: Drums | Satanic Sam And The Pentagrams: Drums |
| JJason CosaNightclub Patron | Nightclub Patron |
| BBrenda CrumNightclub Patron | Nightclub Patron |
| TToby DammitNightclub Patron | Nightclub Patron |
| BBrett DoneluckNightclub Patron | Nightclub Patron |
| JJoseph FuscoNightclub Patron | Nightclub Patron |
| SStaicy FuscoNightclub Patron | Nightclub Patron |
| TThe ImpalerNightclub Patron | Nightclub Patron |
| DDee JonesNightclub Patron | Nightclub Patron |
| RRhianna KalajainenNightclub Patron | Nightclub Patron |
| JJim "Bubba" KuhnNightclub Patron | Nightclub Patron |
| BBrandi LykinsNightclub Patron | Nightclub Patron |
| CChris LykinsNightclub Patron | Nightclub Patron |
| GGary MellenNightclub Patron | Nightclub Patron |
| JJason NorrisNightclub Patron | Nightclub Patron |
| SSaurabh K. SharmaNightclub Patron | Nightclub Patron |
| BBill SpharNightclub Patron | Nightclub Patron |
| FFred WhitacreCoach Wilson | Coach Wilson |
| BBrandon AntoniazziStudent / Heckling Customer | Student / Heckling Customer |