A group of former classmates gather for a pre-party at one of their homes the night before their 10-year high school reunion, and one by one, they are brutally slain in a manner befitting each's senior yearbook superlative.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Heather MorrisGaby | Gaby |
 Ryan DoomBrad Campbell | Brad Campbell |
 Perez HiltonFreddie | Freddie |
 Chad AddisonDJ | DJ |
 Tatum MirandaBella | Bella |
 Jake BuseyTarkin | Tarkin |
 Marci MillerSimone | Simone |
 Skyler ValloAshley | Ashley |
| JJohn DoeThe Graduate | The Graduate |
 Tess ChristiansenJade | Jade |
 Johnny RameyLamont | Lamont |
 Jason TobiasRay Yoder | Ray Yoder |