 Mel GibsonGene Carruthers | Gene Carruthers |
 Mason ThamesNoah Reed | Noah Reed |
 Julian LernerEugene Wexler | Eugene Wexler |
 Abby James WitherspoonSammy Devers | Sammy Devers |
 Noah CottrellBen Driskel | Ben Driskel |
 Nora ZehetnerAbby Reed | Abby Reed |
 Lorraine BraccoMiss Halverson | Miss Halverson |
 Emma FasanoLilly Reed | Lilly Reed |
 Spencer FitzgeraldRonnie Harlow | Ronnie Harlow |
 Patrick RennaUmpire | Umpire |
 Ashley Rae RiddickWitch | Witch |
 Gavin BedellKevin Lampkey | Kevin Lampkey |
 Gary WeeksChief Hartley | Chief Hartley |
 Bobbi BakerHannah Driskel | Hannah Driskel |
 Kelly Collins LintzDeb Harlow | Deb Harlow |
 Nico TirozziLittle Boy / Carruthers' Son | Little Boy / Carruthers' Son |
 Lilah PateEllie Evans | Ellie Evans |
 Kevin JamesEdgar Palmer | Edgar Palmer |
 Barbara GoodsonThe Witch (voice) | The Witch (voice) |
| AAbrielle Josephine CincottiEmily | Emily |
| NNick BenasBaseball Fan (uncredited) | Baseball Fan (uncredited) |
| PParker E. ChickTown Kid (uncredited) | Town Kid (uncredited) |
| SSara Elizabeth EzzellDiner Patron / Pedestrian (uncredited) | Diner Patron / Pedestrian (uncredited) |
 Robert FortunatoPolice Officer (uncredited) | Police Officer (uncredited) |
| KKeeley KollmannMom with Kids (uncredited) | Mom with Kids (uncredited) |
| SSamantha MiroJogger (uncredited) | Jogger (uncredited) |
| AArt NewkirkDad in Theater (uncredited) | Dad in Theater (uncredited) |
| LLogan NewkirkBook Signing Kid (uncredited) | Book Signing Kid (uncredited) |
| VViolet BerlusSkip-It Girl | Skip-It Girl |
| LLara FontesLilly (voice) | Lilly (voice) |
