Two women discover they have the same rock star boyfriend and both think they are the one he is sharing his New York apartment with. When Vinnie returns from a vacation to celebrate his birthday with the girlfriend he expects to find at home, he discovers both women together and that he can't have his cake and eat it too.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Jerry AdlerLimo driver | Limo driver |
| JJudee WalesSis | Sis |
 Beata PozniakErica Chamberlain | Erica Chamberlain |
| PPeter BlackboneVinnie | Vinnie |
 Peter TorkBand manager | Band manager |
| BBob ReedBand Member | Band Member |
| AAmy LevinsonClub Patron | Club Patron |
| DDamon La ScotBand Member | Band Member |
| CCarmine GuidaBand Member | Band Member |
| HHarvey BassClub Patron | Club Patron |