A department store Santa tries to convince a little girl who doesn't believe in Santa Claus that he is Santa Claus, and winds up going on trial to prove who he is.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Sebastian CabotKris Kringle | Kris Kringle |
 Jane AlexanderKaren Walker | Karen Walker |
 David HartmanBill Schaffner | Bill Schaffner |
| SSuzanne DavidsonSusan Walker | Susan Walker |
 Jim BackusShellhammer | Shellhammer |
 Roddy McDowallDr. Sawyer | Dr. Sawyer |
 Tom BosleyJudge Harper | Judge Harper |
 David DoyleMr. Macy | Mr. Macy |
 Ellen WestonCeleste | Celeste |
 Roland WintersMr. Gimbel | Mr. Gimbel |
| BBarry GreenbergAlfred | Alfred |
 James GregoryDistrict Attorney | District Attorney |
 Jason WingreenHalloran | Halloran |
 Conrad JanisDr. Pierce | Dr. Pierce |
 Pepe SernaY Leader | Y Leader |
| JJanice CarrollMrs. Adams | Mrs. Adams |
 Gloria LeRoyMother #1 | Mother #1 |
 Darrell ZwerlingFloorwalker | Floorwalker |
 Jack BernardiShop Owner | Shop Owner |
 Burt MustinRoy | Roy |
 Liam DunnZookeeper | Zookeeper |
 Jerry HardinBellevue Doctor (uncredited) | Bellevue Doctor (uncredited) |