Successful Mary Ann Brubeck adopts a daughter right before Christmas. When bad weather lands her and her new baby stranded in Bethlehem, PA, their only option is to stay with the innkeeper’s brother Joe, a quintessential bachelor.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Laura VandervoortMary Ann Brubeck | Mary Ann Brubeck |
 Benjamin AyresJoe | Joe |
 Amy GroeningFrankie | Frankie |
 Braden BlairTheodore | Theodore |
 Teryl RotheryGoldie | Goldie |
| AAngela NarthGrandma Myrtle | Grandma Myrtle |
| DDarcy FehrShawn Shepherd | Shawn Shepherd |
 Kate TrotterHannah | Hannah |
 Lauren CochraneGabriella | Gabriella |
 John B. LoweGerald | Gerald |
 Paul EssiembrePastor | Pastor |
 Hazel WallaceChoir Soloist | Choir Soloist |
| KKen SteenChurch goer (uncredited) | Church goer (uncredited) |