Sarah is headed back to her hometown for Hanukkah with news of her engagement. Upon returning she finds out that her father had a heart attack and things have gotten out of hand.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Lucy DeVitoSarah Becker | Sarah Becker |
 Jonah PlattBen | Ben |
 Cristián de la FuenteChad | Chad |
| AAdam BuschJacob | Jacob |
 Gina HechtLinda | Linda |
 Bruce NozickFrank | Frank |
 Sarah SilvermanRachel Baum | Rachel Baum |
 Laura SilvermanBecky Baum | Becky Baum |
 Tristan CunninghamJuggler | Juggler |
 Leila WeisbergCrafty | Crafty |
 Natasha Tina LiuAlice | Alice |
 Danvir SinghSagar | Sagar |