 Michael McKiddyHal Donnelly | Hal Donnelly |
 Kim MatulaLacey | Lacey |
 Saige RyanAbigail Donnelly | Abigail Donnelly |
| EEden MalynAmes | Ames |
 Ser'Darius BlainSkip | Skip |
 Alley MillsMartha Donnelly | Martha Donnelly |
 Sam AndersonDouglas Donnelly | Douglas Donnelly |
 Charles RobinsonEdgar | Edgar |
 Dot-Marie JonesPrincipal Ricki | Principal Ricki |
 Emily KurodaMrs. Kibble | Mrs. Kibble |
 Lauren AugartenLauren | Lauren |
 Seth ColtanOfficer Petrey | Officer Petrey |
| RRichard FerrandoWallet Victim #1 | Wallet Victim #1 |
 John GowansBobby | Bobby |
| EElizabeth KhouriDr. Darlene | Dr. Darlene |
 Ross KidderRichie/Family at Pawn Shop | Richie/Family at Pawn Shop |
| RRenee SpeiCindy | Cindy |
 David WeisenbergOffice Manager | Office Manager |
| GGreg DowShady Weed Dealer | Shady Weed Dealer |
| DDaniel ColosimoParty Kid #1 | Party Kid #1 |
 Matthew ConnellParty Kid #2 | Party Kid #2 |
| AAlexander Le BasGawking Teen | Gawking Teen |
| SShane CampbellWeird Guy with Moustache | Weird Guy with Moustache |
| CCynthia J. PoppNurse | Nurse |
| RRick McKiddyWallet Victim #2 | Wallet Victim #2 |
| BBrian ConnellWallet Victim #3 | Wallet Victim #3 |
| EEthan ShumakerWallet Victim #4 | Wallet Victim #4 |
| LLauren AzleinCollege Receptionist | College Receptionist |
| GGeorgina KidderFamily at Pawn Shop | Family at Pawn Shop |
| AAsher KidderFamily at Pawn Shop | Family at Pawn Shop |
