 Carrie AizleyRobyn Wexler | Robyn Wexler |
 Sarah BakerMindy Murray | Mindy Murray |
 Bob BalabanSol Lumpkin | Sol Lumpkin |
 Ed Begley Jr.A.J. Blumquist | A.J. Blumquist |
 Tom BennettOwen Golly, Jnr. | Owen Golly, Jnr. |
 Maria BlasucciJessica Mundt | Jessica Mundt |
 Jennifer CoolidgeJolene Lumpkin | Jolene Lumpkin |
 Kerry GodlimanSarah Golly | Sarah Golly |
| MMatt GriesserAndy Dibble | Andy Dibble |
 Christopher GuestCorky St. Clair | Corky St. Clair |
 John Michael HigginsUpton French | Upton French |
 Michael HitchcockLangston Aubrey | Langston Aubrey |
 Don LakeBuddy Campbell | Buddy Campbell |
 Jane LynchGabby Monkhouse | Gabby Monkhouse |
 Christopher MoynihanPhil Mayhew | Phil Mayhew |
 Chris O'DowdTommy 'Zook' Zucarello | Tommy 'Zook' Zucarello |
 Jim PiddockOwen Golly, Sr. | Owen Golly, Sr. |
 Parker PoseyCindi Babineaux | Cindi Babineaux |
 Harry ShearerCompetition Announcer (voice) | Competition Announcer (voice) |
 Fred WillardGreg Gammons, Jr. | Greg Gammons, Jr. |
 Zach WoodsMike Murray | Mike Murray |
 Susan YeagleyLaci Babineaux | Laci Babineaux |
 Wayne WildersonDr. Harper James | Dr. Harper James |
 Suanne SpokeCavaliers Owner's Wife | Cavaliers Owner's Wife |
 Steven M. PorterCavaliers Owner | Cavaliers Owner |
 Hayes MercureFootball Player | Football Player |
 Suzi Barrett'Does This Smell Normal' Woman | 'Does This Smell Normal' Woman |
 Ryan Gaul'Does This Smell Normal' Man | 'Does This Smell Normal' Man |
| BBrooke HasaltonBushwackers Lap Dancer | Bushwackers Lap Dancer |
| AAdam KarchmerMonty Murray | Monty Murray |
