Winning your childhood sweetheart can create more problems than it solves.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Fran KranzAstor | Astor |
 Dichen LachmanCali | Cali |
 Beau GarrettMila | Mila |
 Caitlin StaseyTrinity | Trinity |
 Enver GjokajJake | Jake |
 Karim SalehFranck | Franck |
 Miracle LaurieJenny | Jenny |
 Felicia DayMary | Mary |
 Maurissa TancharoenHazel | Hazel |
| SSophie KingKirsten | Kirsten |
 Julie MondCutie | Cutie |
 Jonathan OldhamBulldog | Bulldog |
 J.R. StarrHenry | Henry |
 Amelia AlvarezElle | Elle |
| GGenevieve FarrellVictoria | Victoria |
| SSharon WyseAstrid | Astrid |
| JJulie BersaniDivinity Double | Divinity Double |