| JJustin RoseBen | Ben |
 Kelly CurranAllyson | Allyson |
| RRocco GuirlandaProfessor Nolan Gallagher | Professor Nolan Gallagher |
| SSeraphina Anne ZornJennifer | Jennifer |
| SShelby BrunnGrace | Grace |
| DDeacon HaywardPuppy Love Boy | Puppy Love Boy |
| LLouis BadalamentShakespearean Professor | Shakespearean Professor |
| JJeremy KaluzaTeen Boyfriend | Teen Boyfriend |
| CCharlie HuntHorse-Head Man | Horse-Head Man |
| JJon W. MartinBen Senior | Ben Senior |
 Christy EdwardsTracy | Tracy |
| AAmy DrohanGirl in Movie | Girl in Movie |
| KKatelyn KabelRomantic Girl | Romantic Girl |
| HHoward FarmerRude Customer | Rude Customer |
| SSarah DeanStudent at Comedy Club #3 | Student at Comedy Club #3 |
| AAnna BaumanEngineering Student | Engineering Student |
| JJoel BradleyStudent with Sandwich | Student with Sandwich |
| MMegan FluhartyFemale Street Musician | Female Street Musician |
| LLissa StrodtbeckMom #1 | Mom #1 |
| TTreasheer D. AllisonWoman at Bar | Woman at Bar |
| ZZach BarberMax from High School | Max from High School |
| JJordan BorgesTeen Girlfriend | Teen Girlfriend |
| SSatin QuirozStudent at Comedy Club #2 | Student at Comedy Club #2 |
| RRobert BushaBlind Customer | Blind Customer |
| JJacari BrittonComedy Club MC | Comedy Club MC |
| KKatherine TasmaStudent at Comedy Club #1 | Student at Comedy Club #1 |
| LLogan HurtadoRebound Date | Rebound Date |
| SStacy HaywardMom #2 | Mom #2 |
| JJoseph CassidyCinema Employee | Cinema Employee |
| JJohn StrodtbeckDad #1 | Dad #1 |
