An LA girl, unlucky in love, falls for an East Coast guy on a dating app and decides to surprise him for Christmas, only to discover that she's been catfished. But the object of her affection actually lives in the same town, and the guy who duped her offers to set them up if she pretends to be his own girlfriend for the holidays.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Nina DobrevNatalie Bauer | Natalie Bauer |
 Jimmy O. YangJosh Lin | Josh Lin |
 Darren BarnetTag | Tag |
 James SaitoBob Lin | Bob Lin |
 Rebecca StaabBarb Lin | Barb Lin |
 Harry Shum Jr.Owen Lin | Owen Lin |
 Mikaela HooverChelsea Lin | Chelsea Lin |
 Matty FinochioLee | Lee |
 Heather McMahanKerry | Kerry |
 Fletcher DonovanEric | Eric |
 Kwasi ThomasAdam | Adam |
 Sean DepnerChip | Chip |
 Debbie PodowskiDr. Foye | Dr. Foye |
 Seth WhittakerGareth | Gareth |
 C. Ernst HarthKaraoke Operator | Karaoke Operator |
 Cecilly DayKaraoke Singer | Karaoke Singer |
 Dean PetriwPaper Boy | Paper Boy |
 Mel TuckWalt | Walt |
| SSue SparlinPhyllis | Phyllis |
 Balinder JohalElderly Woman | Elderly Woman |
 Peter CiuffaConan | Conan |
| AAlthea KayeGrandma June Lyn | Grandma June Lyn |
 Wonita JoyTag's Mom | Tag's Mom |
 Eric PollinsOlder Party Guest | Older Party Guest |
 Andrew ZacharJames | James |
 Darien MartinMike | Mike |
| AAlexandra LainfiestaMike's Wife | Mike's Wife |
 Shaquan LewisRick | Rick |
| MMarco Walker-NgVinny | Vinny |
 Kurtis SzarkaGreg | Greg |