 Tom Everett ScottJoe Matthews / Micah Matthias | Joe Matthews / Micah Matthias |
 Sarah LancasterRachel Troyler | Rachel Troyler |
 Thomas KapanowskiBobby Matthews / Bobby Matthias | Bobby Matthews / Bobby Matthias |
 Kelly McGillisBertha Troyler | Bertha Troyler |
 Nicole BadaanKim | Kim |
 Annie KitralLydia Troyler | Lydia Troyler |
| KKatherine DeBoerChloe Styles | Chloe Styles |
| MMarianna AlacchiAnna Troyler | Anna Troyler |
 Ken StrunkEli Troyler | Eli Troyler |
 Greg ViolandEd Spencer | Ed Spencer |
| JJohn EbySam Phillips | Sam Phillips |
| GGeoffrey HoffmanDylan Matthias | Dylan Matthias |
| KKaitlyn SappElise | Elise |
 Chris Van VlietReporter #1 | Reporter #1 |
| JJeannie MadisonReporter #2 | Reporter #2 |
| MMadison BlakeYpung Rachel Troyler | Ypung Rachel Troyler |
| DDave McConnellFrank Troyer | Frank Troyer |
 Joe KurakHead Official | Head Official |
| DDave DurchDisheveled Guy | Disheveled Guy |
| KKyle PrimousMechanic | Mechanic |
 Serena MillerCashier | Cashier |
| KKris LeiterUmpire | Umpire |
 Mary Anne PrevostMary Anne (Bank Teller) | Mary Anne (Bank Teller) |
| TTrenton HuffBobby Double | Bobby Double |
| AAbe M. YoderHorse & Buggy Wrangler | Horse & Buggy Wrangler |
| NNicole MillerHorse Trainer | Horse Trainer |
| BBlazeBuggy Horse | Buggy Horse |
| CCurtis BlackburnAmish Youths Chasing Buggy | Amish Youths Chasing Buggy |
| JJason BurroughsAmish Youths Chasing Buggy | Amish Youths Chasing Buggy |
| RRyan SchultzGrungy Guy | Grungy Guy |
