 Rebeka RosalesEloise Lopez | Eloise Lopez |
 Audrey VenableMia Nolan | Mia Nolan |
 Ángel Fabián RiveraRoman Todd | Roman Todd |
| NNaivell SteibPatrick Buckley | Patrick Buckley |
| DDrew HolleyMark/The Slob | Mark/The Slob |
 Isabelle JohnsonThe Egotist | The Egotist |
 Michael MorganDicky | Dicky |
 Vincent MassiThe Film Bro | The Film Bro |
 Rick WimberlyThe Catfish Fisherman | The Catfish Fisherman |
| BBen E. WestThe Priest | The Priest |
| MMichelle ChristineThe French Woman | The French Woman |
| HHannah WacholtzThe Gnome Enthusiast | The Gnome Enthusiast |
| VVisionz2turntThe Businessman | The Businessman |
 Maggie PerryThe Kid | The Kid |
| AAaron BrewerThe Boyfriend | The Boyfriend |
| CCarly BrookeThe Girlfriend | The Girlfriend |
| HHannah McCarthyThe Goth Girl | The Goth Girl |
| JJules XaviaThe Book Reader | The Book Reader |
 Grace MontgomeryFailed Date #1 | Failed Date #1 |
| KKyrah GlazeFailed Date #2 | Failed Date #2 |
| AAlec LeBlancFailed Date #3 | Failed Date #3 |
| PPatrick JonesFailed Date #4 | Failed Date #4 |
| LLexa ThompsonFailed Date #5 | Failed Date #5 |
| AAthena LansdellFailed Date #6 | Failed Date #6 |
| KKieran SwartFailed Date #7 | Failed Date #7 |
| JJomo SadlerFailed Date #8 | Failed Date #8 |
| BBodee StarrFailed Date #9 | Failed Date #9 |
| RRachel OppmannFailed Date #10 | Failed Date #10 |
| BBenjamin LambertFailed Date #11 | Failed Date #11 |
