During spring break, Nathan Hanighan returns home with a ring for his high school sweetheart only to find she had fallen for his best friend. Heartbroken, he moves to Angler Island but circumstances force Nathan to return to Shelton Harbor. Living with his grandmother, Hanighan begins falling for his grandmother’s caregiver Miranda his former best friend’s sister.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Kevin SorboCurtis Hanighan | Curtis Hanighan |
 Shelley LongNona | Nona |
 Jason BurkeyNathan Hanighan | Nathan Hanighan |
| PPayton ChristianProm Teen | Prom Teen |
| SSam DaltonMr. Platz | Mr. Platz |
| BBrooke EllisCara | Cara |
| TTaylor BoswellBaby Shower Guest | Baby Shower Guest |
 Jason K. AllenRestaurant Customer | Restaurant Customer |
| AAubrey H. DiefenthalWedding Guest | Wedding Guest |
| HHarry P. CastrosWedding Guest | Wedding Guest |
| JJim BronaughVisitation • Wedding Guest | Visitation • Wedding Guest |
| PPhilipa A. BooyensRival Team Basketball Player | Rival Team Basketball Player |
| FFaith Dianne BakerBasketball Game Spectator | Basketball Game Spectator |
| CCriss CheathamCollege Coach | College Coach |
 Hayden Gael BarnesBasketball Fan | Basketball Fan |
| DDavid G. BakerTeacher | Teacher |