 Ben AffleckJoe Coughlin | Joe Coughlin |
 Elle FanningLoretta Figgis | Loretta Figgis |
 Brendan GleesonThomas Coughlin | Thomas Coughlin |
 Chris MessinaDion Bartolo | Dion Bartolo |
 Sienna MillerEmma Gould | Emma Gould |
 Zoe SaldañaGraciella Suarez | Graciella Suarez |
 Chris CooperChief Irving Figgis | Chief Irving Figgis |
 Remo GironeMaso Pescatore | Maso Pescatore |
 Anthony Michael HallGary Smith | Gary Smith |
 Titus WelliverTim Hickey | Tim Hickey |
 Derek MearsDonnie Gishler | Donnie Gishler |
 Max CasellaDigger Pescatore | Digger Pescatore |
 Robert GlenisterAlbert White | Albert White |
 Chris SullivanBrendan Loomis | Brendan Loomis |
 J.D. EvermoreVirgil Beauregard | Virgil Beauregard |
 Tom VirtueDoctor | Doctor |
| BBenny CiaramelloPaulo Bartolo | Paulo Bartolo |
 Matthew MaherRD Pruitt | RD Pruitt |
 Bruno AmatoJeff | Jeff |
 Michael MantellJack Jarvis | Jack Jarvis |
 Michael ChieffoPastor | Pastor |
 Andrew BongiornoFasani | Fasani |
 Austin SwiftMayweather | Mayweather |
 Mark BurzenskiStatler Guest (uncredited) | Statler Guest (uncredited) |
 Lucy AngeloTrain Passenger (uncredited) | Train Passenger (uncredited) |
 Larry EudeneNorthend Newspaper Vendor (uncredited) | Northend Newspaper Vendor (uncredited) |
 Lexie RothGillette Factory Worker (uncredited) | Gillette Factory Worker (uncredited) |
| KKatie O'MalleyCigarette Girl (uncredited) | Cigarette Girl (uncredited) |
 John BishopDisheveled Man (uncredited) | Disheveled Man (uncredited) |
 Lewis D. WheelerHerald Reporter | Herald Reporter |
