Goth-girl Cindy admires beautiful Laurie from afar, until the night when she dresses as a boy for the prom. Will this gender-bending Cinderella find true love when she leaves behind her little black boot?
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
| CCarmen PlumbCindy | Cindy |
 Dania RamirezLaurie Rodriguez | Laurie Rodriguez |
 Jane LynchGrace | Grace |
| AAnthony WoodsJustin | Justin |
 Alison SudolSinger | Singer |