 Dustin HoffmanJack Crabb | Jack Crabb |
 Faye DunawayMrs. Louise Pendrake | Mrs. Louise Pendrake |
 Chief Dan GeorgeOld Lodge Skins | Old Lodge Skins |
 Martin BalsamMr. Merriweather | Mr. Merriweather |
 Richard MulliganGen. George Armstrong Custer | Gen. George Armstrong Custer |
 Jeff CoreyWild Bill Hickok | Wild Bill Hickok |
 Aimée EcclesSunshine | Sunshine |
 Kelly Jean PetersOlga | Olga |
 William HickeyHistorian | Historian |
 Alan OppenheimerMajor | Major |
 Lou CutellDeacon | Deacon |
 M. Emmet WalshShotgun Guard | Shotgun Guard |
 James AndersonSergeant | Sergeant |
 Jesse VintLieutenant (as Jess Vint) | Lieutenant (as Jess Vint) |
 Thayer DavidRev. Silas Pendrake | Rev. Silas Pendrake |
| PPhilip KenneallyMr. Kane - Drugstore Proprietor | Mr. Kane - Drugstore Proprietor |
 Jack BannonCaptain | Captain |
| RRay DimasYoung Jack Crabb | Young Jack Crabb |
| AAlan HowardAdolescent Jack Crabb | Adolescent Jack Crabb |
 Jack MullaneyCard Player with Full House | Card Player with Full House |
| SSteve MirandaYounger Bear as a Youth | Younger Bear as a Youth |
 Ken MayerSergeant | Sergeant |
 Carole AndroskyCaroline | Caroline |
| RRobert Little StarLittle Horse | Little Horse |
 Cal BelliniYounger Bear | Younger Bear |
 Ruben MorenoShadow That Comes in Sight | Shadow That Comes in Sight |
| SSteve ShemayneBurns Red in the Sun | Burns Red in the Sun |
