Nine-year-old Amy has decided that klutzy neighbor Arthur is the one she's going to marry. However, Arthur is too busy trying, and failing miserably, to get a place on the football team to pay any attention to her. So she comes up with what she thinks are foolproof schemes to get him to succeed, which will give him more time to spend with her. Complications ensue.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
| DDebbie MegowanAmy | Amy |
 William LeslieBill Martin (as Bill Leslie) | Bill Martin (as Bill Leslie) |
 Shary MarshallHelen Martin | Helen Martin |
| JJoy EllisonRosalie | Rosalie |
| RRickey MurrayArthur | Arthur |
 Cheerio MeredithGrandmother Peabody | Grandmother Peabody |
 Jack AlbertsonThe Reporter | The Reporter |
 Jack NicholsonJefferson City Coach | Jefferson City Coach |
 James MillhollinMr. Kramer | Mr. Kramer |
 Doodles WeaverWhitey | Whitey |