 Drew StarkeyRodney | Rodney |
 Aaron DominguezLuis | Luis |
 Isaiah StrattonDet Randall Wycliffe | Det Randall Wycliffe |
 Gary WeeksDet. Bob Simpson | Det. Bob Simpson |
 Pat DortchTearlach O'Rian | Tearlach O'Rian |
 Javon JohnsonJackie Founders | Jackie Founders |
 Jackie GoldstonSally O'Leary | Sally O'Leary |
 Michael Aaron MilliganHenry | Henry |
 Ezekiel AjeigbeLamar Boyd | Lamar Boyd |
 Josh MurrayThe Dark Stranger | The Dark Stranger |
 Lacy CampKathleen Simpson | Kathleen Simpson |
 Pierce PopeYoung Tearlach O'Rian | Young Tearlach O'Rian |
 Patrick G. KeenanKillian O'Leary | Killian O'Leary |
 Andrew HunterAlex | Alex |
 Johanna JowettJoanna O'Day | Joanna O'Day |
 Erin DanglerJulie Devine | Julie Devine |
 Paxton PopeYounger Tearlach O'Rian | Younger Tearlach O'Rian |
 Jason WesleyRobert Hernandez | Robert Hernandez |
 Brett BakerFather of the Bride | Father of the Bride |
| AAlison Maccherone GomezBookstore Customer | Bookstore Customer |
| BBeth FeliceTodd's Mother | Todd's Mother |
 Christina LeidelMara O'Rian | Mara O'Rian |
 Suzie HainesShoplifter | Shoplifter |
 Kyle RiggsTodd Jacobs | Todd Jacobs |
| AAmanda MedinaParty goer | Party goer |
 Karen Wheeling ReynoldsBaker | Baker |
| AAustin HutchinsonJosh Cooper | Josh Cooper |
 Jonathan BedfordAodan O'Rian | Aodan O'Rian |
 Alex PhippsRicky Jenkins | Ricky Jenkins |
| JJake CollisonNot listed | Not listed |
