| JJames HoustonHimself - Host | Himself - Host |
| RRandall BalmerHimself - Professor of Religious Studies, Barnard College | Himself - Professor of Religious Studies, Barnard College |
| JJames BarnwellHimself - Pastor (as Rev. James Barnwell) | Himself - Pastor (as Rev. James Barnwell) |
| GGreg FlintHimself - First Congregational Church (as Pastor Greg Flint) | Himself - First Congregational Church (as Pastor Greg Flint) |
| MMorley HegstromHerself - Principal, Roosevelt Middle School | Herself - Principal, Roosevelt Middle School |
| EEbony JohnsonHerself - Prevention Outreach Worker | Herself - Prevention Outreach Worker |
| SShelagh JohnsonHerself - Cascade AIDS Project | Herself - Cascade AIDS Project |
| EEvert KettingHimself - Professor of Sociology | Himself - Professor of Sociology |
| BBristol PalinHerself - Teen Pregnancy Ambassador (archive footage) | Herself - Teen Pregnancy Ambassador (archive footage) |
| DDeborah RoffmanHerself - Sexuality & Family Life Educator (as Debbie Roffman) | Herself - Sexuality & Family Life Educator (as Debbie Roffman) |