Christian, a hunky, 20-something, West Hollywood party boy gets more than he bargains for when he tries to seduce Aaron, a sexually confused Mormon missionary who moves into his apartment complex.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Steve SandvossElder Aaron Davis | Elder Aaron Davis |
 Wes RamseyChristian Markelli | Christian Markelli |
 Jacqueline BissetLila Montagne | Lila Montagne |
 Joseph Gordon-LevittElder Paul Ryder | Elder Paul Ryder |
 Rebekah JohnsonJulie Taylor | Julie Taylor |
 Mary Kay PlaceSister Gladys Davis | Sister Gladys Davis |
 Erik PalladinoKeith Griffin | Keith Griffin |
 Amber BensonTraci Levine | Traci Levine |
 Khary PaytonAndrew | Andrew |
 Rob MacElder Harmon | Elder Harmon |
 Dave PowerElder Gilford | Elder Gilford |
 Jim OrtliebBrother Farron Davis | Brother Farron Davis |
| JJudee MortonNoreen | Noreen |
| RRobert LacroixQuinn (Elizabeth's Date) | Quinn (Elizabeth's Date) |
 Terry SimpsonDirk | Dirk |
 Brian Patrick WadeStacy | Stacy |
| KKurt HarganStacy's Husband | Stacy's Husband |
 Jason-Shane ScottChristian's Sublet | Christian's Sublet |
| DDaryl Burq PearsonChurch Elder | Church Elder |