Benning continues his examination of Americana in this film through the stories of two murderers. Ed Gein was a Wisconsin farmer and multiple murderer who taxidermied his victims in the 1950s. Bernadette Protti was a California teenager who stabbed a friend to death over an insult in 1984.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
| RRhonda BellBernadette Protti | Bernadette Protti |
| EElion SucherEd Gein | Ed Gein |
| EEve E. EllisTennis Player | Tennis Player |
| LLisbeth JettonGirl on Phone | Girl on Phone |
| PPegge WinslowWoman Dancing | Woman Dancing |
| JJohn BenningHunter | Hunter |
| RRusty JohnsonMan at Farm | Man at Farm |
| DDorothy ZeidmanNarrator (voice) | Narrator (voice) |
| CChris CordesFBI Interrogator (voice) | FBI Interrogator (voice) |
| IIra ShapiroAttorney (voice) | Attorney (voice) |
 Ron VawterProsecutor (voice) | Prosecutor (voice) |