 Nicolas CageJohn Koestler | John Koestler |
 Rose ByrneDiana Wayland | Diana Wayland |
 Chandler CanterburyCaleb Koestler | Caleb Koestler |
 Ben MendelsohnPhil Bergman | Phil Bergman |
 Nadia TownsendGrace Koestler | Grace Koestler |
 Terry CamilleriCashier | Cashier |
 Lara RobinsonLucinda Embry / Abby Wayland | Lucinda Embry / Abby Wayland |
 Adrienne PickeringAllison | Allison |
 Danielle CarterMiss Taylor (1959) | Miss Taylor (1959) |
 Alethea McGrathMiss Taylor (2009) | Miss Taylor (2009) |
| DDavid LenniePrincipal Clark (1959) | Principal Clark (1959) |
| DD.G. MaloneyThe Stranger | The Stranger |
 Alan HopgoodRev. Koestler | Rev. Koestler |
| JJoshua LongYounger Caleb | Younger Caleb |
| TTamara DonnellanLucinda's Mother | Lucinda's Mother |
| TTravis WaiteLucinda's Father | Lucinda's Father |
 Liam HemsworthSpencer | Spencer |
 Harli AmesMan in Duffle Coat | Man in Duffle Coat |
 Alyssa McClellandFlight Attendant | Flight Attendant |
 Gareth YuenDonald | Donald |
 Lesley Anne MitchellStacey | Stacey |
 Raymond ThomasTeacher | Teacher |
 Angie DiazReporter | Reporter |
 Kate MyliusStudent (uncredited) | Student (uncredited) |
 Sarah LawrenceNew York Model (uncredited) | New York Model (uncredited) |
 Carolyn Shakespeare-AllenPrincipal (2009) | Principal (2009) |
| NNathaniel KiwiParamedic | Paramedic |
| BBlair VennParamedic | Paramedic |
 Menik GooneratneWoman with Baby | Woman with Baby |
 Jim KnobelochArmy General | Army General |
