Four young men fall in love with the same woman. When they all find themselves attracted by Kimberly, hey vow not to fight for her affections during the season -- but then she gets pregnant and doesn't know which teammate is the father.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Gabrielle AnwarKimberly | Kimberly |
 Sean AstinBob | Bob |
 Patty DukeDr. Feinstenberger | Dr. Feinstenberger |
 Jim GaffiganJim at the Ad Agency | Jim at the Ad Agency |
| PPeggy CaffertySalesgirl in Babyshop | Salesgirl in Babyshop |
 Veronica AlicinoSara | Sara |
 Jason LewisScott | Scott |
 Robert MailhouseWalter | Walter |
 Christopher RydellMichael | Michael |
 Molly RingwaldNancy | Nancy |