A series of unsolved crimes from the past prove to be the common thread in three stories that intertwine to reveal big problems in a small town.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Corbin BernsenJennings Wilhite | Jennings Wilhite |
 Dee WallaceSarah Fairchild | Sarah Fairchild |
 Paige MossWendy | Wendy |
| JJeanine MeyersLiz | Liz |
| BBridgette BrooksSusan | Susan |
 Andrea LangiTina | Tina |
| JJoakim AlvarezRiko | Riko |
| SScott RomanJeff | Jeff |
 Tim CarrPaul | Paul |
| LLarry BeyahDJ | DJ |
 Bob AdrianBoard Member | Board Member |
| FFrank BonsangueBoard Member | Board Member |
| MMelvin L. CauthenBoard Member | Board Member |
 Sherman RobertsBoard Member | Board Member |
| GGregory WoodKiller | Killer |
| SSusan MosesDottie | Dottie |
 Brian Anthony WilsonCarl | Carl |
 Joey PerilloDetective | Detective |
| JJohn MarcionettiAshton Killbride | Ashton Killbride |
| CConrad KarlsonLibrarian | Librarian |
| CCaprice SerafineLeigh Hackett | Leigh Hackett |
| RRob CarmignaniHedburg | Hedburg |
| JJohn DencziExtra Board Member | Extra Board Member |
| GGeorge OrinExtra Board Member | Extra Board Member |
| BBrandon E. BrooksMourner / Student | Mourner / Student |
 Adam C. EdwardsMourner / Student | Mourner / Student |
 Tony Luke Jr.Victim In Woods | Victim In Woods |
| GGreg Salvato Jr.Hatchetman | Hatchetman |