True crime super-fan, Will Wesley, has seen it all, but tonight a face in the dark may outsmart him.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Timmy HanlonWill Wesley | Will Wesley |
 Yisrael DubovJohnny Ulbricht | Johnny Ulbricht |
| KKatrina CurrowPenny | Penny |
| AAnastasia LutzJessica | Jessica |
| ZZachary OlinColin | Colin |
| EElizabeth Hirsch-TauberEmma | Emma |