John and Abby Reynolds are a married couple who have been together since their days as high school sweethearts—when John was a football hero and Abby dreamed of becoming a writer.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Jennie GarthAbby Reynolds | Abby Reynolds |
 Fiona VroomBeth | Beth |
 Dan PayneJohn Reynolds | John Reynolds |
 Corbin Bernsen“Pops” Chapman | “Pops” Chapman |
 Chanelle PelosoNicole Reynolds | Nicole Reynolds |
 Markian TarasiukYoung John | Young John |
 Jay HindleSam Taylor | Sam Taylor |
 Devielle JohnsonPastor Mike | Pastor Mike |
 Laura JayeHotel Manager | Hotel Manager |
 James RittingerKade Reynolds | Kade Reynolds |
 Ona GrauerCharlene | Charlene |
| Markian TarasiukYoung Justin | Young Justin |
 Mackenzie MowatYoung Abby | Young Abby |
 Andrew JenkinsMatt | Matt |
 Daniel BaconStan | Stan |
 Andy NezCoach Sol | Coach Sol |
 Kelly KonnoGabrielle | Gabrielle |