The McLean and Brennan ranches are both losing cattle to rustlers and each blames the other when cattle buyer Graves is the real culprit. To throw suspicion off himself Graves hires Tim to investigate, not knowing that this will be his downfall.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Tim McCoyTim Condon | Tim Condon |
 Billie SewardJanet McLean | Janet McLean |
 Ward BondBob Brennan | Bob Brennan |
 Guy UsherHadley Graves | Hadley Graves |
 Edward LeSaintJohn McLean | John McLean |
 Allan SearsPinto Carew | Pinto Carew |
 Jack RockwellRawhide | Rawhide |
 Jack RutherfordLafe Brennan | Lafe Brennan |
 George 'Gabby' HayesJohn Coffin, known as Pegleg Sanderson | John Coffin, known as Pegleg Sanderson |