Four years after the disappearance of her teenage daughter, a mother teams with the FBI to investigate another crime committed by the prime suspect.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Tracy PollanBeth Holloway | Beth Holloway |
 Stephen AmellJoran Van Der Sloot | Joran Van Der Sloot |
 Scott CohenJohn Q. Kelly | John Q. Kelly |
 Amy GumenickNatalee Holloway | Natalee Holloway |
 Michael BeachAgent Delaney | Agent Delaney |
 Francesco QuinnRicardo Flores | Ricardo Flores |
 Julio Oscar MechosoDet. Martinez | Det. Martinez |
 Melissa PonzioDebra Stanville | Debra Stanville |
 Grant ShowJug Twitty | Jug Twitty |
| SSari CummingsThai dancer | Thai dancer |
 Silas CooperFBI Agent | FBI Agent |
 Bruce Gerard Brown Jr.F.B.I. Recordist | F.B.I. Recordist |
| AAaron UribeMale Cop | Male Cop |