 Josh HollowaySelf | Self |
| DDallas JessupSelf | Self |
| CCatherine WehageSelf | Self |
| BBrian MartinekSelf (as Chief Brian Martinek) | Self (as Chief Brian Martinek) |
 Evangeline LillySelf | Self |
| CChad Von DetteSelf | Self |
| PPark MaguireRapist • Abductor | Rapist • Abductor |
| MMatthew WadzitaDate Rapist | Date Rapist |
| AAnthony NealRapist • Abductor | Rapist • Abductor |
| SSamantha AlmanzaPartygoer | Partygoer |
| KKarissa AndersonAudience Member | Audience Member |
| PPaul BattsonPartygoer | Partygoer |
| SStephen BersaniDrunk Friend | Drunk Friend |
| EEmily Clare BiggsPartygoer (as Emily Biggs) | Partygoer (as Emily Biggs) |
| SSierra BinderAudience Member / Partygoer | Audience Member / Partygoer |
| JJason BrubakerPartygoer | Partygoer |
| MMichelle BrubakerAudience / Woman Getting On Bus | Audience / Woman Getting On Bus |
| MMonica BrubakerAudience Member / Partygoer | Audience Member / Partygoer |
| EEmily CarlsonPartygoer | Partygoer |
| NNicky CleggAudience Member | Audience Member |
| EEllie DanielsAudience Member / Partygoer | Audience Member / Partygoer |
| AAshley DelaplaineAudience Member | Audience Member |
| NNoelani S. DixonAudience Member / Woman at Bus Stop | Audience Member / Woman at Bus Stop |
| GGarrett DonahuePartygoer | Partygoer |
| JJordan DonahueDrunk Friend | Drunk Friend |
| RRachel DunlopWoman With Pink Purse | Woman With Pink Purse |
| MMarcus DupontPartygoer | Partygoer |
| AAshley GarnerAudience Member | Audience Member |
| SSophie GistAudience Member / Partygoer | Audience Member / Partygoer |
| MMaria GonzalesAudience Member | Audience Member |