Simon is a teenage boy with a problem: he appears to like girls, but he is also attracted to boys. The proposal was to follow Simon as he attempts to come to terms with his sexual identity.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
| MMitchel David FederanSimon | Simon |
 Seana KofoedHannah | Hannah |
 James McCauleyButch | Butch |
 Carly McKillipSuzie | Suzie |
 Brett KellyJackson | Jackson |
 Andrea BrooksJennifer | Jennifer |
 Nicole FraissinetAlly | Ally |
 Raven GoodwinCrystal | Crystal |
 Taylor HillMelanie | Melanie |
| MMark HoeppnerLeather Guy | Leather Guy |
 Christie LaingAmy | Amy |
 Ryan KennedyGraham | Graham |
 Kristin KowalskiGail | Gail |
| BBill MeilenNot listed | Not listed |
| NNicole PotvinBeverly Davis | Beverly Davis |
 Rondel ReynoldsonCasting Director | Casting Director |
 Reece ThompsonTommy Kinkade | Tommy Kinkade |
 Brittany TipladyMandy | Mandy |
| JJustine WongNot listed | Not listed |