When a woman's first love suddenly reenters her life, her relationship with a charming, but abusive neurosurgeon is upended, and she realizes she must learn to rely on her own strength to make an impossible choice for her future.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Blake LivelyLily Bloom | Lily Bloom |
 Justin BaldoniRyle Kincaid | Ryle Kincaid |
 Jenny SlateAllysa | Allysa |
 Brandon SklenarAtlas Corrigan | Atlas Corrigan |
 Hasan MinhajMarshall | Marshall |
 Kevin McKiddAndrew Bloom | Andrew Bloom |
 Amy MortonJenny Bloom | Jenny Bloom |
 Alex NeustaedterYoung Atlas Corrigan | Young Atlas Corrigan |
 Isabela FerrerYoung Lily Bloom | Young Lily Bloom |
 Robert ClohessySheriff | Sheriff |
 Robin S. WalkerDoctor Johnson | Doctor Johnson |
 Emily BaldoniDoctor Julie | Doctor Julie |
 Adam MondscheinDoctor Dunbar | Doctor Dunbar |
 Caroline SiegristKatie | Katie |
 Robyn LivelyMs. Byland | Ms. Byland |
 Megan RobinsonMs. Smith | Ms. Smith |
 Steve MonroeRealtor | Realtor |
 Daphne ZelleFemale Waiter | Female Waiter |