Most love stories are about losing love or finding it. This is a story about what happens in between.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Josh PenceEric | Eric |
 Spencer GrammerRachel | Rachel |
 Nate CorddryTony (as Nathan Corddry) | Tony (as Nathan Corddry) |
 Bonnie SwencionisGretchen | Gretchen |
 Tom BloomDr. Rice | Dr. Rice |
 John ForestGary | Gary |
 Melissa RauchCarrie | Carrie |
 Charles SocaridesJosh | Josh |