Lyle and Holly, a happily married New York couple decide to test the romantic boundaries of their monogamous relationship. Soon, a hypothetical love triangle with their rock star neighbor becomes a reality they must now navigate.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Chris ParnellLyle Ayker | Lyle Ayker |
 Cara BuonoHolly Ayker | Holly Ayker |
 Dennis HaysbertHoyt Johnston | Hoyt Johnston |
 Illeana DouglasEthel | Ethel |
 Willow ShieldsGreta Ayker | Greta Ayker |
| TTim RealbutoLouie | Louie |
| EEve AustinKiki | Kiki |
 Steve LichtensteinWalter | Walter |
| BBeau AllenParty Host | Party Host |
| AAnthony Cumberbatch Jr.Bouncer | Bouncer |
 Jerry DiLeoBusiness Man | Business Man |
| PPete DortonCousin Brent | Cousin Brent |
| LLeslie LemonBass Player | Bass Player |
 Dominic MarcusWendell | Wendell |
| KKathrina MiccioIsabella | Isabella |
| JJames PravasilisDanny | Danny |
| TThomas Joseph PryorParty Host | Party Host |
| JJenilyn RodriguezCate | Cate |
| AAlixx SchottlandAnna | Anna |
 Sammy SmedleyKat | Kat |
 Judy TomaCousin Ellen | Cousin Ellen |
| JJohnny VorstegChad | Chad |
| TThomas VorstegGabe | Gabe |