 Paula AbdulPaula Abdul | Paula Abdul |
 Joe GattoJoe Gatto | Joe Gatto |
 James MurrayJames Murray | James Murray |
 Brian QuinnBrian Quinn | Brian Quinn |
 Sal VulcanoSal Vulcano | Sal Vulcano |
 Jaden SmithJaden Smith | Jaden Smith |
 Joey FatoneJoey Fatone | Joey Fatone |
| SSalvatore Volcano Sr.Pop Volcano | Pop Volcano |
 Evan CastelloeFrat Bro #1 | Frat Bro #1 |
 Sierra PondStaten Island '94 Girl | Staten Island '94 Girl |
 Madison BaileyBowling Alley Girl | Bowling Alley Girl |
 Jessica Megan RiveraUnimpressed Backstage '94 Girl | Unimpressed Backstage '94 Girl |
 Sailor LarocqueMiami Restaurant Girl #1 | Miami Restaurant Girl #1 |
 Andrea AndradeMiami Restaurant Girl #2 | Miami Restaurant Girl #2 |
 Camille RobinsonMiami Restaurant Girl #3 | Miami Restaurant Girl #3 |
 Will FerrellMiami Restaurant Guy #4 | Miami Restaurant Guy #4 |
 Josefina BoneoMiami Panicked Girl | Miami Panicked Girl |
| GGuilherme ApollonioMiami Hotel Valet | Miami Hotel Valet |
 Jordan Sherley'94 Concert Panicked Girl | '94 Concert Panicked Girl |
| MMark Jigarjian1994 Ticket Attendant | 1994 Ticket Attendant |
| DDrew McDermottBusker Guitar Player | Busker Guitar Player |
| TTiago FerreiraSoldier Stranded in Boat | Soldier Stranded in Boat |
| CChase Dominick1st Mate | 1st Mate |
 Casey MillsCashier - Rest Shop | Cashier - Rest Shop |
| KKatherine EsparzaHigh School Girl '94 | High School Girl '94 |
| GGregory Neil Howard Jr.Tour Guide | Tour Guide |
 Casey JostSam | Sam |
| JJenna ElkadiMiami Party Girl | Miami Party Girl |
 Kane HodderBodyguard | Bodyguard |
| JJeff GloverBouncer (uncredited) | Bouncer (uncredited) |
