It's an hour before Lucy's wedding and her best friend wants to hear all about what led up to that moment. So, Lucy tells about the five men she had blind dates with over the past year (Doug, Gabriel, Bobby, Barry, and Luke) and her experiences with each one. But which one of the five men is Lucy about to walk down the aisle with?
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Monica PotterLucy | Lucy |
 Julianne NicholsonJo | Jo |
 Flora MartínezMelissa | Melissa |
 Harold RamisJack | Jack |
 Julie ChristieDori | Dori |
 Craig BierkoPeter | Peter |
 John HannahDate 1 - Doug | Date 1 - Doug |
 David BoreanazDate 5 - Luke | Date 5 - Luke |
 Gael García BernalDate 2 - Gabriel | Date 2 - Gabriel |
 Anthony LaPagliaDate 3 - Bobby | Date 3 - Bobby |
 Henry ThomasDate 4 - Barry | Date 4 - Barry |
 Robert KleinDr. Mort Zalkind | Dr. Mort Zalkind |
 Ray BokhourAlan Jackson | Alan Jackson |
 John TormeyTommy | Tommy |
 Woodwyn KoonsFront Row Girl | Front Row Girl |
| LLinda HalaskaSaleslady | Saleslady |
 Julie GonzaloEve | Eve |
 Afemo OmilamiCab Driver #1 | Cab Driver #1 |