| RRachel PfennigwerthAmanda | Amanda |
| DDustin AndrewsMichael | Michael |
| EEmily MooreAshley | Ashley |
| NNicholas ZarzecznyMatthew | Matthew |
 Julia SilvermanAmanda's Mother | Amanda's Mother |
| RRon LakeAmanda's Father | Amanda's Father |
| EEthan LyversTyler | Tyler |
| AAngela Katherine BakerStephanie | Stephanie |
| LLaura Irene YoungJessica | Jessica |
 Joe FishelCongressman | Congressman |
| BBrian CeponisChief of Staff Richard Patterson | Chief of Staff Richard Patterson |
| JJessica BuckBrittanny | Brittanny |
 Michael Z. AtrataDating Service Owner | Dating Service Owner |
| BBenjamin SheelerLandscaper | Landscaper |
 Angel R. ReedCongressman's Wife | Congressman's Wife |
 Jeff MonahanFuneral Speaker | Funeral Speaker |
| CChristopher KaiAshley's Martial Arts Date | Ashley's Martial Arts Date |
| RReed MackAshley’s Older Date | Ashley’s Older Date |
 Alex BlairAshley’s Disco Date | Ashley’s Disco Date |
| RRyan BeatriceAshley's Bigfoot Date | Ashley's Bigfoot Date |
| NNelia Rose HolleyTheater Director | Theater Director |
| DDawn ReneeRobby Neal's Mother | Robby Neal's Mother |
 John W. IwanonkiwRobby Neal's Father | Robby Neal's Father |
| FFrank PermanStand-Up Comedian | Stand-Up Comedian |
| BBrett Sullivan SantryLord Macbeth Actor | Lord Macbeth Actor |
| AAlyssa HerronLady Macbeth Actress | Lady Macbeth Actress |
| GGregory JohnstoneTheater Patron | Theater Patron |
| KKristine BeckettBarista #1 | Barista #1 |
| CCheryl L. SoriceBarista #2 | Barista #2 |
| HHannah MrosBarista #3 | Barista #3 |
