Ever since killing the Fisherman one year ago, Julie James is still haunted by images of him after her. When her best friend Karla wins free tickets to the Bahamas, Julie finds this a perfect opportunity to finally relax. But someone is waiting for her. Someone who she thought was dead. Someone who is out again for revenge.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Jennifer Love HewittJulie James | Julie James |
 Freddie Prinze Jr.Ray Bronson | Ray Bronson |
 Matthew SettleWill Benson | Will Benson |
 Brandy NorwoodKarla Wilson | Karla Wilson |
 Mekhi PhiferTyrell | Tyrell |
 Muse WatsonBen Willis | Ben Willis |
 Jennifer EspositoNancy | Nancy |
 Bill CobbsEstes | Estes |
 Jeffrey CombsMr. Brooks | Mr. Brooks |
 John HawkesDave | Dave |
 Ellerine HardingOlga | Olga |
 Benjamin BrownDarick the Dockhand | Darick the Dockhand |
 Red WestPaulsen | Paulsen |
 Michael P. ByrneThurston | Thurston |
 Michael Bryan FrenchDoctor | Doctor |
| DDee Anne HelselNurse | Nurse |
| JJohnny HarringtonTodd | Todd |
 Mark Boone JuniorPawn Shop Owner | Pawn Shop Owner |
| SSylvia ShortOld Woman | Old Woman |
 Jack BlackTitus Telesco (uncredited) | Titus Telesco (uncredited) |
 Spencer KaydenCocktail Guest (uncredited) | Cocktail Guest (uncredited) |
 Summer MooreClassmate (uncredited) | Classmate (uncredited) |
| TTanya RaisaClub Goer (uncredited) | Club Goer (uncredited) |