 Marie OsmondJosephine "Josie" Marcus | Josephine "Josie" Marcus |
 Bruce BoxleitnerWyatt Earp | Wyatt Earp |
 John Bennett PerryJohn Behan | John Behan |
 Jeffrey DeMunnDoc Holliday | Doc Holliday |
 Alison ArngrimAmy | Amy |
 Ross MartinJacob Spiegler | Jacob Spiegler |
| RRon ManningVirgil Earp | Virgil Earp |
| JJosef RainerMorgan Earp | Morgan Earp |
| CCharles BentonIke Clanton | Ike Clanton |
| EEarl W. SmithFrank Stillwell | Frank Stillwell |
| RRon ChapmanMarsh Williams | Marsh Williams |
| EElayne SteinMama Speigler | Mama Speigler |
| DDee MaaskeMattie Earp | Mattie Earp |
| LLinda Rae JurgensLouisa Earp | Louisa Earp |
| DDonna BrownAllie Earp | Allie Earp |
| CClaud HerefordBud Philpot | Bud Philpot |
 Joseph BottomsThe Driver | The Driver |
| TTom AssaloneBilly Clanton | Billy Clanton |
| RRandy WellsFrank McLaury | Frank McLaury |
| JJoe CorcoranTom McLaury | Tom McLaury |
| JJanet Marie HeilRuth | Ruth |
| KKirk KoskellaSherm McMasters | Sherm McMasters |
| BBecky BronssonMember of the Pirates of Penance Troupe | Member of the Pirates of Penance Troupe |
| JJan SandwichMember of the Pirates of Penance Troupe | Member of the Pirates of Penance Troupe |
| KKaryn MarshMember of the Pirates of Penance Troupe | Member of the Pirates of Penance Troupe |
 Jerry WillsLuther Walters | Luther Walters |
| GGene AltobelloThe Waiter | The Waiter |
| BBilly WineThe Hotel Clerk | The Hotel Clerk |
| RRobert DetweillerThe Stage Manager | The Stage Manager |
| IInez PerezJuanita | Juanita |