 Fredric MarchJonathan / Nathaniel / Samuel / Wallace Wooley | Jonathan / Nathaniel / Samuel / Wallace Wooley |
 Veronica LakeJennifer | Jennifer |
 Robert BenchleyDr. Dudley White | Dr. Dudley White |
 Susan HaywardEstelle Masterson | Estelle Masterson |
 Cecil KellawayDaniel | Daniel |
 Elizabeth PattersonMargaret | Margaret |
 Robert WarwickJ. B. Masterson | J. B. Masterson |
 Georgia BackusOlder Woman (uncredited) | Older Woman (uncredited) |
 Charles BatesWooley's Son (uncredited) | Wooley's Son (uncredited) |
 Brooks BenedictCountry Club Guest (uncredited) | Country Club Guest (uncredited) |
 Billy BevanPuritan Vendor (uncredited) | Puritan Vendor (uncredited) |
| EEdward BibySpectator at Fire (uncredited) | Spectator at Fire (uncredited) |
 Marie BlakePurity Sykes (uncredited) | Purity Sykes (uncredited) |
 Monte BlueDoorman (uncredited) | Doorman (uncredited) |
 Aldrich BowkerJustice of the Peace (uncredited) | Justice of the Peace (uncredited) |
 Al BridgeSecond Prison Guard (uncredited) | Second Prison Guard (uncredited) |
 Nora CecilHarriet Wooley (uncredited) | Harriet Wooley (uncredited) |
 Ann CarterJennifer Wooley (uncredited) | Jennifer Wooley (uncredited) |
 Chester ConklinParty Bartender (uncredited) | Party Bartender (uncredited) |
 Gordon De MainMan with Masterson on Radio (uncredited) | Man with Masterson on Radio (uncredited) |
 Emma DunnWife of Justice of the Peace (uncredited) | Wife of Justice of the Peace (uncredited) |
 Ralph DunnFirst Prison Guard (uncredited) | First Prison Guard (uncredited) |
| MMary FieldNancy Wooley (uncredited) | Nancy Wooley (uncredited) |
 Bess FlowersMatron of Honor (uncredited) | Matron of Honor (uncredited) |
| JJoe GilbertWedding Guest (uncredited) | Wedding Guest (uncredited) |
| FFlorence GillWoman Playing Chess (uncredited) | Woman Playing Chess (uncredited) |
 Robert GreigTown Crier (uncredited) | Town Crier (uncredited) |
 Eily MalyonTabitha Wooley (uncredited) | Tabitha Wooley (uncredited) |
 Charles R. MooreRufus - Samuel's Servant (uncredited) | Rufus - Samuel's Servant (uncredited) |
| VViola MooreMartha (uncredited) | Martha (uncredited) |
