The story of Elizabeth Smart's kidnapping and captivity, as told from her perspective.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Alana BodenElizabeth Smart | Elizabeth Smart |
 Skeet UlrichBrian David Mitchell | Brian David Mitchell |
 Deirdre LovejoyWanda Barzee | Wanda Barzee |
 George NewbernEd Smart | Ed Smart |
 Anne OpenshawLois Smart | Lois Smart |
 Elizabeth SmartHerself - Narrator (voice) | Herself - Narrator (voice) |
 Sarah Madison BarrowOlivia | Olivia |
| GGraem BeddoesGrocery Clerk | Grocery Clerk |
 Jazmine CampanaleYoung Woman Driver | Young Woman Driver |
| LLondon CardinalWilliam Smart | William Smart |
| EEthan FarrellAndrew | Andrew |
 Peter Graham-GaudreauNevada Bus Driver | Nevada Bus Driver |
| DDevin JohnstonDave | Dave |
| CChelsey MooreWoman In Library | Woman In Library |
 Cassidy NugentMary Katherine | Mary Katherine |
 Kiefer O'ReillyEdward | Edward |
| RRobin T. RoseRadio Man | Radio Man |
 Natalie von RotsburgNot listed | Not listed |
 JJ WebbJogger | Jogger |