| QQudus AgbelegaDead Body in Hallway (segment "American Hell") | Dead Body in Hallway (segment "American Hell") |
 Mark AshworthMan (segment "American Hell") | Man (segment "American Hell") |
| AAbella BalaEden (segment "Penace") | Eden (segment "Penace") |
 Steven T. BartlettDr. Friedkin (segment "Nails") | Dr. Friedkin (segment "Nails") |
| MMaria BoasSasha (segment "Mother") | Sasha (segment "Mother") |
| KKolbe BoudreauxThe Demon (segment "Penace") | The Demon (segment "Penace") |
| BBrittany N. BrownDead Body in Hallway (segment "American Hell") | Dead Body in Hallway (segment "American Hell") |
| JJeffery James BucchinoDead Body in Hallway (segment "American Hell") | Dead Body in Hallway (segment "American Hell") |
| PPaul Campa(segment "Swim with Me") | (segment "Swim with Me") |
| GGabriel Carli-JonesDaniel (segment "Nails") | Daniel (segment "Nails") |
| LLoren CollinsScreaming Neighbors on VHS (segment "American Hell") | Screaming Neighbors on VHS (segment "American Hell") |
| BBristol CoxDead Body in Hallway (sement "American Hell") | Dead Body in Hallway (sement "American Hell") |
| NNicole CoxDead Body in Hallway (segment "American Hell") | Dead Body in Hallway (segment "American Hell") |
| BBen EscobarThe Witch (segment "Swim with Me") | The Witch (segment "Swim with Me") |
| EEdmund FayThe Invisible Man (segment "Invisible Man") | The Invisible Man (segment "Invisible Man") |
 Hannah FiermanGeneva (segment "American Hell") | Geneva (segment "American Hell") |
| JJessica FoyLouise (archive footage) | Louise (archive footage) |
| BBrandi GrollDead girl being dragged (segment "American Hell") | Dead girl being dragged (segment "American Hell") |
| TTroy HalversonMan in Office (segment "American Hell") | Man in Office (segment "American Hell") |
| JJp HuckinsMother (segment "Mother") | Mother (segment "Mother") |
| BBecky KapScreaming Neighbors on VHS (segment "American Hell") | Screaming Neighbors on VHS (segment "American Hell") |
 John KapVirgil (segment "American Hell") | Virgil (segment "American Hell") |
| NNeely KapScreaming Neighbors on VHS (segment "American Hell") | Screaming Neighbors on VHS (segment "American Hell") |
| IIsaac KiedrowskiDead Body 2 (segment "Swim with Me") | Dead Body 2 (segment "Swim with Me") |
| RRebecca LindleyJanice (archive footage) | Janice (archive footage) |
| VVelton LishkeDoctor (archive footage) | Doctor (archive footage) |
| AAustin MatteDead Body 4 (segment "Swim with Me") | Dead Body 4 (segment "Swim with Me") |
| GGrace MeihausMom (segment "Mother") | Mom (segment "Mother") |
 Joshua MikelDaemon (segment "American Hell") | Daemon (segment "American Hell") |
| LLane MillerJohn the Neighbor (segment "American Hell") | John the Neighbor (segment "American Hell") |