Upon leaving London and working at a cooking hotline, Abby connects with an anonymous caller — a single dad who Abby unknowingly is also smitten with in real life.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Emily TennantAbby | Abby |
 Niall MatterJack | Jack |
 Erik AthavaleRoger | Roger |
 Sydney SabistonAddie | Addie |
 Dan De JaegerTony the Mafia Guy | Tony the Mafia Guy |
 John B. LoweGary | Gary |
| CCora MathesonErica | Erica |
 Myla VolkJessica | Jessica |
 Jan SkeneDiane | Diane |
 Michael StricklandMike | Mike |
 Lindsay NanceTami | Tami |
 Kalyn BombackCarla | Carla |
 Jean-Jacques JavierChris | Chris |
 Marina Stephenson KerrMargaret | Margaret |
 Jacob BlairJason | Jason |
 Candace SmithThelma | Thelma |
 Lois BrothersHoliday Hotline Operator #2 | Holiday Hotline Operator #2 |
 Henriette IvanansHoliday Hotline Operator #3 | Holiday Hotline Operator #3 |
 Lisa Marie DiGiacintoAudrey | Audrey |
 Matthew LupuGordi | Gordi |
| JJudith HarperShirley | Shirley |
 Cheryl SolukJudy | Judy |
 Andrea del CampoKimberly | Kimberly |