After Evie dresses up like her estranged grandmother, a Holocaust survivor, on “Heritage Day” at school, she becomes increasingly obsessed with this dark part of her family history.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Rachel BloomSarah | Sarah |
 Vivien Lyra BlairEvie | Evie |
 Scott Michael FosterJames | James |
 Sierra KatowGreta | Greta |
 Alex Jayne GoNicole | Nicole |
 Pam MurphyMargot | Margot |
 Kirk FoxChip | Chip |
| HHaely WhiteCharlene | Charlene |
 Micaiah ChenStacey | Stacey |
 Lennon GraceGrace | Grace |
| TTamara PerryBetty | Betty |
| DDewey JamisonOllie | Ollie |