After the events of the first film, the masked superhero Closet-Man has gained some notoriety and now has new challenges to face: evil robots, arson, and his own enslavement to The Nightmare Room. Will he make it out with his life?
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Feck SpeiderbeckCloset-Man / Crone / Keith | Closet-Man / Crone / Keith |
| JJustin FaxonCMC1000 | CMC1000 |
| WWendy FarfidianHerself | Herself |
| AAlex ChevezChevez | Chevez |
| DDaniel LamplughDr. Arson | Dr. Arson |
| KKatie MichaelThe Figure | The Figure |
| CChristian ChesnutShleppi Henderson | Shleppi Henderson |
| JJean-Paul JeunesseThe Collector | The Collector |
| IIan GlotfeltyLazer-Man | Lazer-Man |