| PPaul McCloskeyWayne Montgomery | Wayne Montgomery |
| BBarbara LessinAndrea Montgomery | Andrea Montgomery |
 Brinke StevensJulie | Julie |
| BBruce DeSantisTodd Montgomery | Todd Montgomery |
| EEmily SpiegelMonica Montgomery | Monica Montgomery |
| MMichael J. Panichelli Jr.Detective John Haynes | Detective John Haynes |
| JJeff WatsonJoe Mitchell | Joe Mitchell |
| TTanisha DungeeTeresa Mitchell | Teresa Mitchell |
| BBenjamin P. Ablao Jr.Detective Chris Dolendo | Detective Chris Dolendo |
| JJoey GarrisonJared | Jared |
| SStacey LoweryOlivia Hutton | Olivia Hutton |
 Dave WascavageRichard Kemmerling | Richard Kemmerling |
| MMelissa TorrenceKaren Wilson | Karen Wilson |
| BBeth SikmaKim | Kim |
| EErick KnieslerJonathan | Jonathan |
| BBill JacksonMatt | Matt |
| NNiki KehagiasMarcia | Marcia |
| SShree HolmanDiana | Diana |
| KKate HollowayHolly | Holly |
| JJay CusackJeffrey | Jeffrey |
| YYolanda IrizarryJuanita | Juanita |
| DDebra Lee WylieVictim | Victim |
| FFran SlaczkaWomen's Retreat Victim #1 | Women's Retreat Victim #1 |
| SSue MorrowWomen's Retreat Victim #2 | Women's Retreat Victim #2 |
| KKaren KennedyWomen's Retreat Victim #3 | Women's Retreat Victim #3 |
| MMary BrownWomen's Retreat Victim #4 | Women's Retreat Victim #4 |
| SSteve BrownPastor Vernon Cole (deleted scenes) | Pastor Vernon Cole (deleted scenes) |
| DDenise SmileyCarolyn Jackson (deleted scenes) | Carolyn Jackson (deleted scenes) |
| JJohn LarsenRon Hayford (deleted scenes) | Ron Hayford (deleted scenes) |
| CChris KellerAmy (deleted scenes) | Amy (deleted scenes) |
