 Seth PetersonRobbie Levinson | Robbie Levinson |
 Bruce DavisonPastor Boyd | Pastor Boyd |
 Chad DonellaChris Boyd | Chris Boyd |
 Cindy PickettBarbara McCoy | Barbara McCoy |
 Brian J. SmithTrey McCoy | Trey McCoy |
 Susan BlakelyMartha Boyd | Martha Boyd |
 Lin ShayeKathleen Slansky | Kathleen Slansky |
 Farah WhiteDet. Elizabeth Fisher | Det. Elizabeth Fisher |
 Giancarlo EspositoDetective Esposito | Detective Esposito |
 Sean HenniganJim McCoy | Jim McCoy |
 Brandy LittleStella | Stella |
| BBen BathmanConnor Davis | Connor Davis |
| LLuke KingAlton Kachim | Alton Kachim |
| EEarl Browning IIIDetective Loy | Detective Loy |
 Scarlett McAlisterDoctor Kucera | Doctor Kucera |
| CConnor Gewin4-year-old Trey | 4-year-old Trey |
| TTyler Farris10-year-old Trey | 10-year-old Trey |
| TTrevor Sterling StovallFisher's Son | Fisher's Son |
| JJason Hair-WynnBoy in Jail (uncredited) | Boy in Jail (uncredited) |
| PPreston StrotherBoy in Church (uncredited) | Boy in Church (uncredited) |
| TTyler StrotherBoy in Church (uncredited) | Boy in Church (uncredited) |
| CCyrus ThompsonBoy in the Park (uncredited) | Boy in the Park (uncredited) |
| TTom MarcantelFather Tim | Father Tim |
| HHana KappSalesperson | Salesperson |
| CCas DodgenPoliceman | Policeman |
 Brock CravyYoung Man | Young Man |
| KKellie RasberryCarla, Robbie's Coworker | Carla, Robbie's Coworker |
 Dee HenniganDaycare Teacher | Daycare Teacher |
| KKeni LaTronicoRobbie's Mother (as Keni la Troncio) | Robbie's Mother (as Keni la Troncio) |
| VVernon ReevesSeth's Father | Seth's Father |
