 Brooke BradshawVeronica (New Years) | Veronica (New Years) |
| WWesley AlleyUncle Bob (Christmas) | Uncle Bob (Christmas) |
| WWhitney AlleyParty Guest (Christmas) | Party Guest (Christmas) |
 Michael AntosyEran Lawrence (Easter) | Eran Lawrence (Easter) |
| AAmy BakliniDoctor's Voicemail (voice) | Doctor's Voicemail (voice) |
| RRonan BarbourDoyle (St. Patrick's Day) | Doyle (St. Patrick's Day) |
| AAdam BeigelKris Anderson (Christmas) | Kris Anderson (Christmas) |
 Michelle BernardJudy (Chanukah) | Judy (Chanukah) |
 Darren Lynn BousmanOrignial Killer Santa (Christmas) | Orignial Killer Santa (Christmas) |
 Alexandra BoylanJosi (Thanksgiving) | Josi (Thanksgiving) |
 Arielle BrachfeldGirl in Woods (Halloween) | Girl in Woods (Halloween) |
| HHannah CarletonHome Buyer (Halloween) | Home Buyer (Halloween) |
| BBrian C. ChenworthNew Killer Santa Clause (Christmas) | New Killer Santa Clause (Christmas) |
 Micah CohenParty Goer (New Years) | Party Goer (New Years) |
| BBrandon ConnerJeffery (Halloween) | Jeffery (Halloween) |
 Ivet CorveaGloria (4th of July) | Gloria (4th of July) |
 Francis CroninSheamus G (St. Patrick's Day) | Sheamus G (St. Patrick's Day) |
| TTaylor CrossDan (New Years) | Dan (New Years) |
| LLenora ElisabethCiara (St. Patrick's Day) | Ciara (St. Patrick's Day) |
 Michael J. EpsteinMr. Keane (St. Patrick's Day) | Mr. Keane (St. Patrick's Day) |
 Bradley FowlerParty Guest (Christmas) | Party Guest (Christmas) |
| CCharlie FrohneRadio News Reporter (Easter) (voice) | Radio News Reporter (Easter) (voice) |
| JJohn K.D. GrahamMonster (Thanksgiving) | Monster (Thanksgiving) |
 Josh HammondJesse (4th of July) | Jesse (4th of July) |
| AAlethea Hnatko-ChoClara (St. Patrick's Day) | Clara (St. Patrick's Day) |
| CChristopher M. JimenezParty Guest (Christmas) | Party Guest (Christmas) |
| BBreeanna JudyParty Guest (Christmas) | Party Guest (Christmas) |
| DDarius KarsasFather Time (New Years) | Father Time (New Years) |
| NNeil KingParty Guest (Christmas) | Party Guest (Christmas) |
| EErica LamkinLaura (Labor Day) | Laura (Labor Day) |